Matching your belt with your shoes is actually quite simple if you stick to a few basic rules. This guide will explain the fundamental principles of matching your belt and shoes and answer some frequently asked questions on the topic.
Match the Leather Color
This is the primary rule to know and follow to be 100% safe (and stylish). That's it, on to the next topic!
Well, let's wait for a minute. While this rule is straightforward in theory, in practice, new shoes might not match the exact shade of your existing belt or briefcase. Generally speaking, the greater the contrast between your belt and shoes (or accessories), the less stylish it will appear. However, slight differences in tone are usually not a big deal.
As a general rule: matching colors always work. Dark brown shoes go with a dark brown belt, oxblood shoes with an oxblood belt, and so on. When these colors are perfectly matched, people will subconsciously perceive you as someone who pays attention to detail and knows what they’re doing—even those who aren’t fashion-savvy.
Match the Metals
The same principle applies to metals, like the buckle on your belt. Its color should match the metal accents on your shoes (and ideally, other metals you wear, like watches, chains, rings, etc.). Monk strap shoes, for example, have prominent buckles that should be coordinated with your belt buckle. Gold with gold, silver with silver, and so on. A notable exception are accessoires with sentimental value, like for example your wedding ring. These items don't need to match, though it will always look better if they do.
Breaking The Rules
They say you should only break the rules once you understand them. The rules mentioned above are general guidelines but not set in stone. Why not try something different? To provide some assurance, here are answers to some frequently asked questions:
Can You Wear Black Shoes with a Brown Belt?
The answer here is a clear "No." Black and brown are fundamentally different tones—black is cool, brown is warm. Black shoes deserve a black belt, especially for formal occasions. No matter how much effort you put in, this combination will always look like a last-minute decision with whatever shoes and belt you had in your wardrobe.
Can You Wear Different Shades of Brown?
Yes. Light brown shoes with a chocolate brown belt can work because they are both shades of brown. If the shoes have a darker heel and sole, this enhances the match. The goal should always be to convey a sense of cohesion in the colors, as this exudes competence in color coordination.
What Belt Do You Wear with Black or Gray Shoes?
Black shoes can sometimes be paired with a gray belt, and gray shoes can be paired with a black, gray, or even dark blue belt. Black and gray are neutral tones and can somewhat match each other. However, this is a risky choice. The rest of the outfit must also fit. This combination should not be chosen for a classic suit or tuxedo, but rather for something more casual. This approach is generally reserved for those who are highly confident and fashion-conscious, able to carry such an outfit with the necessary self-assurance.
What Belt Do You Wear with Oxblood Shoes?
The color oxblood is generally quite striking. Therefore, only an oxblood belt can maintain the color balance. Mixing brown and oxblood can make the outfit look too busy.
What Belt Do You Wear with Two-Tone Shoes?
The belt color should match the dominant color of the shoes. A perfect match is not necessary, but the closer the color, the better. For example, a dark brown belt works well with shoes that are mainly dark brown with blue suede accents.
Conclusion
Rules can be broken, but in most cases, the classic combination of matching colors always looks excellent. This approach is generally very reliable. If you truly know what you’re doing, feel free to break the rules. However, if you prefer to play it safe, sticking to these tried-and-true principles is the best bet.
